How to Identify the Best Leadership Style for Your Team

One of the most important aspects of being an effective leader is knowing how to adapt your leadership style to the needs of your team. Leadership isn't a one-size-fits-all approach; different teams, depending on their culture, dynamics, and goals, require different styles of leadership. So, how do you know what type of leadership style is best for your team? In this article, we’ll break down key factors to help you assess your team’s needs and determine the most effective leadership approach.

Understanding Leadership Styles

Before diving into how to determine the best style for your team, let’s briefly review some of the most common leadership styles:

Transformational Leadership: Inspires and motivates teams toward a long-term vision, fostering innovation and change.

Democratic Leadership: Encourages team input and collaboration, valuing collective decision-making.

Servant Leadership: Focuses on the well-being and growth of the team, putting the team's needs first.

Autocratic Leadership: Makes decisions independently and provides clear direction, ideal for quick decision-making or when strict control is needed.

Coaching Leadership: Prioritizes personal and professional development by guiding individuals toward achieving their potential.

Each of these styles has its strengths, but they are only effective when aligned with the needs of the team they’re managing.

1. Assess the Current Dynamics of Your Team

The first step in identifying the right leadership style is understanding your team’s unique dynamics. Are they self-sufficient, or do they need more guidance? Are they motivated by personal development, or do they work better under structure?

Here's how to evaluate:

Skill Level: Teams that consist of experienced and highly skilled members may benefit from a transformational or democratic leadership style, where creativity and input are encouraged. On the other hand, if your team is less experienced or needs more direction, a coaching or autocratic style might be more appropriate.

Work Ethic and Motivation: If your team members are highly motivated and need little supervision, a servant or democratic style may work best, as they can thrive with more autonomy. If motivation is an issue, a transformational leader can inspire and energize the team.

Team Cohesion: A well-bonded team that works well together can benefit from transformational or democratic leadership. However, if your team struggles with communication or collaboration, a servant leader may be the best option to rebuild trust and camaraderie.

 2. Consider Your Team’s Current Goals

Your team’s objectives can also provide insight into which leadership style will be most effective.

Short-Term Goals: If your team is working on a time-sensitive project, you may need to adopt a more autocratic or transactional leadership style to ensure efficiency and meet deadlines.

Long-Term Goals: For teams focused on innovation, growth, or cultural change, a transformational leadership style is likely to produce the best results by keeping everyone focused on the vision and motivated to push boundaries.

Individual Development Goals: If your team is in the process of skill-building or professional development, a coaching leadership style would ensure each team member is given the attention and guidance necessary to grow.

3. Gauge Your Team’s Need for Autonomy vs. Structure

Not all teams are the same when it comes to how much autonomy they need. Some teams work better with freedom, while others perform best when given a clear structure.

High Autonomy: If your team excels in independent work and decision-making, a democratic or servant leadership style could provide the freedom they need to innovate and collaborate. Leaders who encourage input and trust their team to make decisions often find that this autonomy leads to higher satisfaction and better performance.

Need for Structure: For teams that prefer more guidance or are newer to their roles, a coaching or autocratic style provides a framework for them to learn and grow within a structured environment. Autocratic leaders, for instance, offer clear direction and minimize the decision-making burden on the team.

4. Understand the Emotional Intelligence of Your Team

Another key consideration is the emotional and interpersonal intelligence of your team. How do they handle feedback, conflict, or change?

High Emotional Intelligence: Teams with high emotional intelligence are often better at handling change and feedback, making them ideal candidates for transformational or democratic leadership styles, where innovation and collaboration are essential.

Low Emotional Intelligence: Teams with lower emotional intelligence may struggle with feedback or autonomy. In these cases, servant or coaching leadership styles, which focus on personal growth and support, can help improve communication and emotional resilience.

5. Get Feedback from Your Team

One of the most effective ways to determine the right leadership style is to simply ask your team for feedback. This can be done through surveys, one-on-one meetings, or group discussions.

Ask About Their Needs: Find out what kind of support your team members feel they need from you as a leader. Do they prefer autonomy, or do they thrive under structure and guidance?

Inquire About Their Motivation: Understanding what motivates your team is key to choosing the right leadership style. Are they motivated by personal growth, recognition, or achieving long-term goals? Their answers can provide insight into whether a coaching, transformational, or democratic approach will work best. 

6. Be Ready to Adapt

Finally, it’s important to note that your leadership style may need to change as your team evolves. Effective leaders are adaptable and capable of switching styles based on changing team dynamics, goals, or challenges.

Adapt to Growth: As your team becomes more skilled or takes on new responsibilities, you may find that a transformational or democratic leadership style becomes more appropriate than the more structured autocratic or coaching styles.

Adapt to Challenges: In times of crisis or rapid change, you may need to shift to a more autocratic style to provide clear direction and maintain control until the situation stabilizes.

There is no one perfect leadership style. The key to becoming a successful leader is the ability to assess your team’s needs, understand the context of your goals, and adapt your leadership style accordingly. By considering your team’s skill level, goals, emotional intelligence, and need for autonomy or structure, you can determine which style will drive the best results. And remember—great leaders are always willing to adjust their approach as their team grows and evolves.

Are you looking to improve your leadership skills and adapt your management style for greater effectiveness? Subscribe to our newsletter for more leadership insights and actionable strategies to help you lead with impact and purpose.

Let me train your team! Message us today :)